|
Pages :
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
[ 16]
17
18
19
20
GMScud 08-21-2007, 08:45 PM I don't have time to read all 150 posts in this thread, but I wonder if the $1M we were to pay Marshall had anything to do with it.
It is curious that we would hang on to other lesser players like Khary Campbell and Sartz and let Lemar go. He wasn't much of a MLB, but OLB pretty well. Godfrey is a solid player. I'm hoping that bringing him in isn't an indication the Marcus' injury is worse than reported.
SmootSmack 08-21-2007, 08:58 PM I don't have time to read all 150 posts in this thread, but I wonder if the $1M we were to pay Marshall had anything to do with it.
It is curious that we would hang on to other lesser players like Khary Campbell and Sartz and let Lemar go. He wasn't much of a MLB, but OLB pretty well. Godfrey is a solid player. I'm hoping that bringing him in isn't an indication the Marcus' injury is worse than reported.
I'm sure money definitely played a role. As for Campbell and Sartz, not only are they cheaper depth alternatives they are younger. Marshall is no spring chicken.
More than money and age though, the Redskins must have seen or not seen something lately with Marshall that made them think they need someone right now.
(on a side note, I kind of like this WR they signed Jerel Myers. He could be a good #5 receiver)
70Chip 08-21-2007, 08:59 PM I'm sure money definitely played a role. As for Campbell and Sartz, not only are they cheaper depth alternatives they are younger. Marshall is no spring chicken.
More than money and age though, the Redskins must have seen or not seen something lately with Marshall that made them think they need someone right now.
(on a side note, I kind of like this WR they signed Jerel Myers. He could be a good #5 receiver)
What do you know about Myers, oh Connected One? Sincerely curious.
81forHOF 08-21-2007, 09:01 PM I don't like it. Why cut him now when we don't have to? What happens if Rocky blows out his acl next week against the Ravens...we will look real stupid. Just like when we cut Bramlet and JC hurts his knee the next week and Brunnel continues to look like crap.
Or another team could lose their WLB and then we could get something for him. Just like Atlanta jumping on Bramlet...surely they would have given us something for him or at least pursued Brunnel more. It just doesn't make sense to cut someone with value now. And don't give me the old 'we were be nice by letting him go early' bit. This is after all a business, as we have been repeatedly reminded.
Also, how does the rest of the team react to losing one of their own for what appears to be hardly any reason. way to look out for your 'core Redskins'.
Finally, I have seen Marshal make big plays for this team. Everyone else has yet to show that to me - potential or no.
SmootSmack 08-21-2007, 09:07 PM What do you know about Myers, oh Connected One? Sincerely curious.
Played at LSU, most recently tearing up the AFL (not hard to do I suppose). About 5'11" 190ish. Big play type of receiver, good deep threat. His biggest strength is probably his speed after the catch. Dante Hall-esque with better size
70Chip 08-21-2007, 09:10 PM Let's see what Williams says about it. This was his call. He may give us some clue. My position at this point is the simplest explanation is the best: he got outplayed. This would make more sense if they had not brought in Godfrey which makes it seem like they are not completely satisfied with the play of the others.
As for the timing, I think they wanted to avoid putting him to the curb with the rest of the first cut garbage. It's a small concession to his service for the team that will be better for him. No, it's not the necessarly the savviest or most cutthroat thing they could have done. But it's not likely they would have gotten that much, if anything, for him. If you are willing to trade a guy at this point, chances are you are going to cut him at some point anyway and other teams know this.
70Chip 08-21-2007, 09:12 PM Played at LSU, most recently tearing up the AFL (not hard to do I suppose). About 5'11" 190ish. Big play type of receiver, good deep threat. His biggest strength is probably his speed after the catch. Dante Hall-esque with better size
Sounds like a Santana xerox. Thanks.
holcknowsbest 08-21-2007, 09:16 PM anyone have some names they would like to throw out there that the redskins should sign. either potential cuts, unsigned vets???
sandtrapjack 08-21-2007, 09:23 PM Assuming this isn't a bogus lead - anyone know anything interesting about Randall Godfrey? For instance:
1) Why he wasn't on a roster
2) Is he broken
3) Why no one has spoken about him this offseason
4) If he was a bear, what kind of bear he would be
5) Favorite Power Ranger
I don't care who you are, that is FUNNY!
Pocket$ $traight 08-21-2007, 09:31 PM Personally, I thought Marshall had value since he could play Middle and outside. I also thought that he looked pretty good in the Steelers scrimmage. I highly doubt that this was a cap move so there has to be a good reason, right!?!?
|