Fins Cut Culpepper...Who picks him up?

Definitely would rather have Brunell. Putting aside the fact that we don't know how Daunte's knees are, consider that we're-I assume-talking about signing Culpepper as a backup to Campbell (not to replace him). I want my backup, especially to a young QB like JC, to be able to serve as a mentor and know the offense.

Culpepper doesn't know this offense and I don't think he has any intention of being anyone's mentor. For the role the backup has to serve on our team, give me Brunell any day.


I disagree, 1- Brunell is old, and takes up a lot of cap space while Culpepper is hitting his prime age. 2- We have two old players that "know the system", if we drop brunell then collins would still be there.
Right now we have no young back up unless you count what we'll have on the practice squad.
Culpepper came back too early, and that affected him. It's not like he had time to learn his WR's or the system. That would be a huge upgrade for us.

No way Brunell plays this year barring injury.

^^ lets just hope nothing crazy happens and the fans start calling for him. No more QB controversy

You actually provide a very good point NOT to sign him. I am sick of QB controversies. But if Cambell sucks, then this whole season is shot.

No way Brunell plays this year barring injury.

But injuries are a huge part of the game. Not even Manning takes 100% of the snaps...although he comes DAMN close.

If Campbell sucks I will cry like a little girl.

But injuries are a huge part of the game. Not even Manning takes 100% of the snaps...although he comes DAMN close.


yes it is but I see Campbell starting 15 games, not the lasr one cause we will have home-field wrapped up.

But injuries are a huge part of the game. Not even Manning takes 100% of the snaps...although he comes DAMN close.

When is the last time he missed any significant playing time during a meaningful game? Or Tom Brady?

Unless we're not serious about Campbell, I don't think there is anything to gain from signing Culpepper to be a backup.

If Campbell sucks I will cry like a little girl.

I think we all will...and quite frankly, I feel it's there is a 40% chance of that happening. I am hoping he is going to have a 3500 yard season with 25 tds and 12 ints...up to 15 ints.

If I recall, Ramsey was never allowed not to come to the facility. He just got benched because of poor performance.

I don't recall that Ramsey got benched for poor performance. If I remember correctly, he had over a 100 yards in a quarter and a half and had thrown for one touchdown (called back through no fault of Ramsey's) when he was benched for almost the whole season. I also remember that in Ramsey's last game as a Redskin he had a quarterback rating of about 180 and led the Skins in a playoff win against the Giants, only to then be benched for good and traded.

The Skins should pick up Culpepper, but they won't. Once again, Gibbs' judgment about Brunell is in the way of sanity as well as being a monumental irritant. Campbell goes down, Skins go down. We have the weakest backup in the NFL. I'd give five Brunells and faily decent bucks for Culpepper. I'd also cut our other worthless backup and bring up Casey for the third option.

yes it is but I see Campbell starting 15 games, not the lasr one cause we will have home-field wrapped up.

LOL, he'll still start the 16th game to get the practice, but come out around half time.