ROY re-hashed!

You know who had a great rookie year? LT Marcus McNeil of the ChargersI was really shocked that he was getting so much pub. I mean, it drew a lot of attention to a rookie LT having a great year, but there are so many other linemen that get no coverage, I'm wondering what McNeil did so right.

That was a heckuva class at Auburn though in 04-05.

VY is going to be a good QB in this league and if you compare his number to Peyton's first year they are about the same.

Ummm what? I audibly laughed at this one. That might be one of the most absurd comments I have heard.
56.7% comp, 3739 yards, and 26 td's...how exactly do those stats compare to the stats of Young? Did you mean Young's numbers compared to Mannings after Manning played his first 9 games or something?

Why not just start a thread that read Jones Is a "Fun Player To Watch" then people would have commented only on Jones and not VY.

Well, technically it was my fault for comparing Young to Jones-Drew in the first place...but since Young didn't deserve it, it naturally belongs in this thread.
Still, does it matter? If it was purely about Vince young was overrated, then that would be the name of the thread.

You realize that you are setting yourself up for a Gus Frerotte joke right? Something like, pure passing qb's don't hesitate to headbutt walls.


You got me there!!!!!!!!! But Gus had a cannon, so does Young, both will end their careers without ever holding a Lombardi Trophy though

Actually I don't see any need to defend him, he won ROY... end of story.

I just don't know why we need multiple threads bashing Young.

Young is very good, just don't see him winning a title with the team he is on, or with his style of play. He is on par with Vick with regards to athletic ability, actually somewhat superior with regards to arm strength, but if he starts to really dance around like Vick does he is going to take some mega punishment and might end up like Donovan. Folks are taking bets as to how long MCNabb is going to last this season. I say by week 9-10 he will be hurt. Would love to see Landry knock him on his butt a few times on saftey blitzes!!!!!! Better yet would like him to do an impression of when Carrier(Lions) knocked Keyshawn out cold several years back in TB!!! Still the nastiest hit I have seen. Down goes Keyshawn! Down goes Keyshawn!!

You got me there!!!!!!!!! But Gus had a cannon, so does Young, both will end their careers without ever holding a Lombardi Trophy though

Ramsey had a "cannon" but it doesnt mean jack shit. Sorry to bring up this old thread, but I dont see how your favorite Redskins could even be Gus.

Ramsey had a "cannon" but it doesnt mean jack shit. Sorry to bring up this old thread, but I dont see how your favorite Redskins could even be Gus.

I think we've all scratched our head at that one, but hey, some people are just a glutton for punishment.