Who Is The Better Evaluator Of Talent Mcshay Or Kiper Jr.?

These guys are okay but NOBODY can ever predict how prospects will be at the NFL level.I agree with you to an extent JankySpanky, that at a majority of the positions where there is insuffient data to draw any correlations between characteristics of a bust or successful prospect, it takes some amount of good fortune to land the right guy.

I just think that we've been cultured by the "experts" to think the draft is a complete crapshoot when in reality, that's just an excuse for them not doing their jobs. I bet Mel Kiper wouldn't tell you the draft is a crapshoot.

every year mayock takes someone and falls in love with him. last year it was cutler. this year its c Johnson. he cant hold kipers jockAdditionally, Mike Mayock said that Sean Taylor would be the best prospect to come out of the 2004 draft.

No matter where you stand on Taylor's value to this team, I think we can all agree that he is not the best prospect to come out of the 2004 draft.

To me I feel that Kiper is way better more and more I seem to see that McShay doesn't know what he is talking about but what do you guys think?I'd like to see Kiper's final mock draft before the actual draft and see how many he gets right also previous years.

last year i think kiper had like 26 out of 32. pretty good for such a crapshoot.

Man, you're going to have to put some more substance to your posts sir.


sorry man i will make them longer

Man, you're going to have to put some more substance to your posts sir.

What

Man, you're going to have to put some more substance to your posts sir.

Are

Man, you're going to have to put some more substance to your posts sir.

You

Man, you're going to have to put some more substance to your posts sir.

Talking

Man, you're going to have to put some more substance to your posts sir.

About