Tom "Iceman" Brady

way to go "iceman." Can this be over for now? peyton just beat brady, and brady cost the pats the game with that pick and peyton and his team won. i know all the brady lovers will say, its just one game but whatever peyton won, brady blew it with that pick, period.

are you kidding me, if you wanna be serious about the whole thing, reche caldwell blew the damn game, but your right Brady threw the pick and lost the game for the patriots, so the fact that Brady already has won three superbowls and Peyton has finally made it to one makes Peyton better? I dont understand your logic

What? I can't hear you...

I still dont understand how your arguing this, what has Peyton Manning won yet? Does he have a superbowl ring? Just because he won today doesnt make him better, he still has a lot of catching up to do if you plan on saying hes better than Brady

Payton manning is a better passer while Tom Brady is a better leader. Both are fantastic QB's in their own respects and arguing this is completely useless since some people like the perfect passer and some like the stone cold nothing effects him leader.

you dissagree ?

All I know is the Colts won the game, and the Pats blew an 18 point lead. If what you're saying is right then a break has finally gone against the lucky Patriots. It was a unbelievable game, that's for sure! Glad the Colts have finally gotten the monkey off their back!

I guess Barry Sanders must be almost worthless according to the "Brady is God, Peyton is a chump" crowd.

Man I thought this would be case closed. It almost was. Now I figure we have a legit debate. That was a pretty bad first part of the game for Manning and a Hall of Fame performance afterward. No Denying that. Manning was brilliant in the second half. It's only one game, but I have no doubt Manning has a ring now.

I still dont understand how your arguing this, what has Peyton Manning won yet? Does he have a superbowl ring? Just because he won today doesnt make him better, he still has a lot of catching up to do if you plan on saying hes better than Brady


He just beat Mr. Freeze, that is what he won. He was better than Brady today. Mr. Freeze had several chances to "ice" the game and he blew it. I guess he isn't as great as most of the posters in this thread claim.

are you kidding me, if you wanna be serious about the whole thing, reche caldwell blew the damn game, but your right Brady threw the pick and lost the game for the patriots, so the fact that Brady already has won three superbowls and Peyton has finally made it to one makes Peyton better? I dont understand your logic

I would say that by letting Branch go the Patriots management blew it since "Crazy Eyes" Caldwell shouldn't be a go to guy for anybody.

Payton manning is a better passer while Tom Brady is a better leader. Both are fantastic QB's in their own respects and arguing this is completely useless since some people like the perfect passer and some like the stone cold nothing effects him leader.

What? Manning led his team down the field to win the game with a few minutes left. Brady had several chances to end the game and then threw an INT to end it. Better leader?

you dissagree ?

That was a gift TD for Gaffney. There was no way he would have brought that one down.