TheMalcolmConnection
11-20-2006, 01:01 PM
There's no way in hell Brunell throws those down the field. He also doesn't evade that sack.
Grade Jason CampbellTheMalcolmConnection 11-20-2006, 01:01 PM There's no way in hell Brunell throws those down the field. He also doesn't evade that sack. onlydarksets 11-20-2006, 01:10 PM I'm not suggesting that MB would have made any particular play - and definitely not the throw to Lloyd that was dropped. I'm just saying that, on whole, I would not have given MB a B+ for that level of play (i.e., in terms of bad throws, bad reads, etc.). JC gets the B+ because he played a helluva game for his first time out there, and he showed a LOT of promise. TheMalcolmConnection 11-20-2006, 01:11 PM Indeed. He just needs to tighten up that accuracy a bit. But overall, he was right on the money. Hog1 11-20-2006, 01:28 PM There's no way in hell Brunell throws those down the field. He also doesn't evade that sack. I loved him completing the pass with the defender hanging on his jersey! RiggoRules 11-20-2006, 01:28 PM He gets an A. Why? 1. His poise. 2. He made plays even when the receivers did not. 3. I get to say FU to those who stayed on the #8 bandwagon. Jamaican'Skin 11-20-2006, 01:47 PM I say the kid gets an A closer to a B. He did an excellent job of managing the O, without much help from the run game. 197 yds, no INTs, and 2 tds in your first game? That's better than some starting QBs in the league right now. I'm scared for opposing Ds when Santana gets back. Laser arm + blazing speed= TDs all day FRPLG 11-20-2006, 02:09 PM I said B-/C+ because to me A = Peyton on a good day A-/B+ = Brady on a good day B = Roethlisberger on a good day last year B-/C+ = Brunell on a good day last year He certainly didn't make outstanding plays and adjustments and just play a superb game at QB winning the game for his team for an A. He didn't execute an entire play book and spread the ball around without mistakes and put his team in position to win for an A-/B+ I don't think he quite played mistake free and kept his team chugging along for a B. I do think he played relatively mistake free and gave his team opportunities to make some plays. I think he was on the line between and this and the higher grade but I gave him this since we lost. I think his effort gets an A and his peformance gets a slightly above average B-/C+. If he plays every game like that the rest of his career then he'll win games. Hell we would have won yesterday with an average performance from our defense. Hog's Breath 11-20-2006, 02:44 PM I loved him completing the pass with the defender hanging on his jersey! That was a sweet play. That's what we've been missing with MB. Someone to make a play when the shit is hitting the fan. I gave him a B. Although, after reading the posts, maybe he deserved an A. MTK 11-20-2006, 02:54 PM That was a sweet play. That's what we've been missing with MB. Someone to make a play when the shit is hitting the fan. I gave him a B. Although, after reading the posts, maybe he deserved an A. He really hangs tough in the pocket and keeps his eyes downfield, very refreshing to see. Sheriff Gonna Getcha 11-20-2006, 02:59 PM I said B-/C+ because to me A = Peyton on a good day A-/B+ = Brady on a good day B = Roethlisberger on a good day last year B-/C+ = Brunell on a good day last year. Fair post, but man, haven't you ever heard of grade inflation? | |
EZ Archive Ads Plugin for vBulletin Copyright 2006 Computer Help Forum