McNabb... Heart vs. Head

Here's the deal. Start McNabb. If he has a good day then at least you got some benefit from it. If he has a bad day then at least you got some benfit from it. Starting Rivers is the only way you create a situation where you potentially get pissed on both accounts.

this is why im not a fantasy guy. i cant root for people who are rivals of the skins. u gotta go with rivers

I solved that...I just don't draft any Cowboys or Eagles. I still do well, there are 32 starting QBs out there...not having McNabb won't kill me.

Stats over the last 4 games:

McNabb (DAL, @NO, @TB, JAC): 77-134 (57%), 1064 yds, 7 TDs, 4 INTs, 2 Fum, 1 FL, sacked 11 times
Rivers (@SF, @KC, STL, CLE): 88-133 (66%), 1017 yds, 5 TDs, 1 INT, 2 Fum, 1 FL, sacked 8 times

Starting either wouldn't be a bad choice, since they are both going against subpar Pass Defenses. If I had to choose, I'd take Rivers. I think the Skins D will have something in store for McNabb.

Mcnabb was a late round pick and had scored the most fantasy points of anyone in football up until last week...

He threw 3 picks 3 weeks ago and still got me 31 pts.... He's worth the pickup... I don't ever look at cowboys, but if shokey is available sometimes ill pick him up if there are no other tight ends.

It was nuts how many people were drafting cooley early this year...

I have McNabb and Rivers as my 2 QBs in my money league... and I'm first in my division and leading them by over 100 pts and one win. Im going against the only guy in the league ahead of me this week, in a probable superbowl preview...

Should I start Donovan McNabb against our horrendous pass D? Or do you think we may right the ship and upset this week?

My head says, "no brainer... start mcnabb" but my heart says don't go against your team after last week... we may just shut them down, and mcnabb hasn't been hot the last couple of games, on top of which his stats after a bye arent tops...

Advice... Please....It's not all your heart. As bad as our pass D has been, its about the time when you think that McNabb has a great chance to set a passing record that he completely disappears. That said, you probably have to go with him.

When it comes to Fantasy and I have anyone from the opposing team that the Skins are playing I am more than willing to take a loss in Fantasy for a Skins victory. Whether my league is a pay one or not. That being said, I would think it would be hard to sit McNabb against the Skins 30th ranked D.

Skins 21 Eagles 14

F that... I'm starting Rivers. We're due some turnovers... I think we'll get 2 picks this game. ST getting one and one by a linebacker getting to a pass intended for LJ smith. Rivers doesn't throw picks and yeah, cincy's D wasn't what it was last year...

P. Rivers - 31 points


D. McNabb - 15 pts.


I know we lost, but at least I made the right decision here lol....

one by a linebacker getting to a pass intended for LJ smith.


this was the pick that washington missed, by the way...