Brady or Manning?

Peyton finally has something Brady had all those years....Adam Vinatieri

Peyton finally has something Brady had all those years....Adam Vinatieri

For a second there I thought you were going to say "genital warts;" I'm glad you didn't.

I am young, and I haven't seen all the great QBs play ... but, I think manning is the best QB ever (based on throwing ability and decision making).

... let's not forget that he threw 49 TDs in one season. That's a lot for a single team -- let alone a single player.

Listening to NFL radio today this subject came up. One caller in particular made an excellent point. He says he is sick of hearing the 3 super bowl rings as the reason Brady is a superior quarterback. First of all, it's nearly impossible to base an individual position on winning. Winning comes from a whole team not one person, the only reliable way to look at it is stats, and even those are flawed.

He also said everyone notes how great Brady would be with those receivers, but fail to look at the flip-side. How good would Manning be with that defense?

If given my pick, I'd take Manning in a second. Switch Manning with Brady, and I feel that Manning has 3, maybe more, rings too.
Good points but you can't switch and everytime Peyton has had a chance he has fallen short. Last year the Colts D was ranked 11th in the NFL and with the Colts ability to score that was more than good enough. You can have all the stats in the world but they play to win the SB. As of right now Brady is the only one of them that has done that and I believe they both have about the same number of years playing.

Tom Brady wins no matter who is around him. I like them both and Peyton's numbers are impossible to argue with. However, I think the rings speak louder than anything else. Let's see what happens now that Peyton has Vinatieri, though. I say, let's get through this year and then have this conversation again. I think I'd rather have Manning, but he's not really the great big game QB. Hard to say...one thing I do know, I'd take either over any qb the Skins have had in the last 14 years!

Rings speak louder than anything else? Blah blah, you sound like a Cowboys fan always talking about your rings, lol. Brady didnt get the rings by himself. Vinetari is also a colt now...that man earned those rings as much as brady. Manning was good and won without a defense for many years.

Id have to say Manning, its just somethign special to watch when he was the ball.

If you put both of these players in say... Arizona -- what do you think each would do. That's the true test of whos a better QB.

I think brady would do better in arizona, i feel like he's less of a statue and moves about the pocket better than manning. I feel like brady can make more out of nothing than manning for some reason.

If you put both of these players in say... Arizona -- what do you think each would do. That's the true test of whos a better QB.

Arizona is a bad team to use, bc they have good recievers. Let's say put both on the Raiders, and see who does the best.

Arizona is a bad team to use, bc they have good recievers. Let's say put both on the Raiders, and see who does the best.

jeez Peyton to Randy Moss would be sick

This is Montana Marino all over again...Brady is on a better team...I would take Peyton. If Peyton had New Englands defense all these years he would have a Super Bowl.