Brady or Manning?

I'd give the edge to Manning. I think he's just more of a presence out there. Now, Brady is still a great QB, but I think Manning's definitely got more on his shoulders.

It could be said that Brady has had a great set of talent around him, coaching, defense, he had it all. For years, Manning played with a shitty defense and even then he was basically a coach playing QB.

Brady does a bunch of stuff really well and is a great player.

Peyton is on a whole different level. He may be top five of all time, and could be higher when he's finished.

I'll take Peyton.

To me Tom Brady is just about on the same level with some of the greats of all time and it's Manning who is a step below. Brady does a bunch of stuff better than almost any quarteback I have ever seen. His overall football IQ is higher than Manning who seems to be missing something although nobody is quite sure what that is because his numbers are so ridiculous.

You could easily say though that Manning has had more offensive weapons around him. He's playing with two #1 caliber WRs in Harrison and Wayne. Brady has never had one WR of that quality let alone two. Manning also played for years with Edge. The best back Brady has had is Dillon and they caught him on the downside of his career.

Going back to his college days Manning has never won "the big one".

" the big one?" insert your own joke here

Could you imagine what Brady's numbers could be if he played in a dome?

They're both awesome, cant go wrong either way

peyton=Marino Brady is the man and will be for a long time.

Peyton = Elway

He will get one before it's all over.

by far brady. he is a winner plain and simple

You could easily say though that Manning has had more offensive weapons around him. He's playing with two #1 caliber WRs in Harrison and Wayne. Brady has never had one WR of that quality let alone two. Manning also played for years with Edge. The best back Brady has had is Dillon and they caught him on the downside of his career.

Going back to his college days Manning has never won "the big one".

I think a lot of the greatness from the Indy receivers just comes from the contintuity that there has been in that organization. The level of chemistry among Harrison, Wayne and Manning makes them a lot better than if any of those players went to another system. I'd still take Manning since I think some of the Pats success comes more from the coaching staff, but its very close.

I think a more important question is who do I start this weekend on my fantasy team. NE Defense against Indy, or Indy Defense against NE?