Best coaches of all time

http://sports.espn.go.com/chat/sportsnation/listranker?id=109

This is a very impressive group but we all know who the winner should be

WHen I just did it Gibbs was ranked 3rd for best NFL coach behind Belichick and Parcells.

WHen I just did it Gibbs was ranked 3rd for best NFL coach behind Belichick and Parcells.
And 21st of all time overall. Parcells was 10th in that list.

Just a question here:

How far down on the list might you have to go to find either Bruce Coslett or Richie Kotite?

I'm guessing we are talking about folks in the "Bottom 10"...

Curmudgeon, don't forget Rick Venturi

Steve Spurrier? (Sorry, Daseal! ;) )

Hey, most of you guys don't go back that far, but Otto Graham had a REAL impressive stint as Redskin coach...

Actually, I think Gibbs IS the best coach in sports today. And if he is wildly successful this time, I believe it will place him right at the top all-time with Lombardi. (I really don't think anyone could ever displace Vince at the top, but he may have to share...)

I got a question for the Hogskin and Sportscurmudgeon types on the Warpath (i.e. the older/wiser generation)....tell me about the Pardee era. I know records-wise it wasn't great but was he put in an unfair position since he and Beathard disagreed so much? We hear about Allen all the time and of course Gibbs, but Pardee seems kind of forgotten. So I'd love to hear more about what the team was like back then. And also how did you guys feel the first time the Skins hired Gibbs. Were you excited?

I know I'm not in the "older" generation, but I remember that Pardee wasn't exactly a "player's" coach. I read things about him such as... Q: "How do you know Pardee is lying?" A: "His lips are moving".

I read a recent interview with Dave Butz (Baby!) where he said pretty much the same thing... you never knew where you stood with Pardee and what he told the players to be fact depended on who he was talking to and when. By the time he left to go back to the Univ of Houston, he had pretty much lost all respect from the players.

Any of you "older" folks want to shine any more light on this? I remember him as coach, though I don't really remember the press' account of him at the time...

Well, first I want to say, Pardee was OUTSTANDING as a player. As a coach, I would confirm Butz' comments and add that while my recollection of his stint is not vivid, I seem to recall that he was not a good disciplinarian - too soft. Maybe some others have a clearer memory of it. However, I do not feel he was put in an unfair situation - just another of those coaches that are pretty good on one level, but not as an NFL HC.

I personally did not know much about Joe Gibbs when he first took over as Redskin coach. And, of course, it was not looking too wonderful 5 games into the season (0-5). He sure didn't waste any time AFTER that start making us believers in him, though. The guy I really did not care for at first was Bobby Beathard. Early on, he made several player moves that I was not fond of - especially with some of the team veterans. Turned out Betheard was VERY good at drafting late-round picks, not great with round 1 guys (so it was good that he usually traded them). He and Joe went around and around over some personnel decisions late in his stay here.