Monk vs Reed

until monk is admitted to the hof, the hall won't hold any credibility for me :(

This is the problem they will face with not allowing Monk in. He had very strong numbers so Reed poses a dilemna. They want to put Reed in, because the media LOVED that Bills team, but if they do, they have to answer for Monk and they don't have one. Witness P.K. trying to explain his vote. He can't because the real reason he won't vote for Monk is that he has always despised the Washington Redskins. Period. It's insane and it's an insult. Every other dynasty team gets their props except us. The Packers, the Raiders, the Steelers, the 49ers, soon the Cowboys, and the Vikings, My God, the Vikings. Apparently we won all of our Super Bowls on the strength of Coach Gibbs and John Riggins which is amazing since Riggins didn't play in the last two. Good for you, John!

The reality is that the Bills were a very good team in a lousy conference and some folks just never got the memo. (But they went to four straight Super Bowls. You can't forget that, blah, blah, blah). Exactly. The AFC was that bad. They had to send somebody.

I predict they will put Reed in before Monk and we'll hear how his impact was different than Monk's. (I just think that Reed really embodied the spirit of that team, yada, yada, yada). And they'll harp on the 19 TDs till they're blue in the face. Whatever they can think of to avoid telling the truth. And if you think I'm paranoid, check out the SportsCenter thread. More proof! I believe they have sent Tafkas to watch us. (Just kidding) (Maybe)

The noise for Monk being in the Hall is definitely getting louder. Particularly from ESPN, i.e. Tom Jackson, Michael Irvin, Tre Wingo (sp).

I feel a lot better about Monk getting now than I did last year around the same time. Peter King can only voice his opinion for so long.

Monk will get in, and the Hall will be all the better for it!!!

Andre Reed holds the record for receiving yardage in the Super Bowl, I think.

Super Bowl Records - SuperBowl.com - Official website of Super Bowl XLI (http://www.superbowl.com/history/records/indiv/receiving)

Rice owns the Super Bowl record for most career yards gained with 589. Reed is 3rd with 323.

Rice also owns the record for single game yardage with 215, our Ricky Sanders is 2nd with 193.

Rice pretty much owns most of the receiving records, surprise, surprise.

We can talk about this all we want but the discussion is just so old now. It makes me tired to even think about it. It is so obviously a slight that what can you say? How do you prove to people who won't listen that 2+2=4? It just does.
Art Monk not being in the HOF is the biggest slight in all of professional Hall of Fames right now without fail. The race isn't even close.

exactly, FRPLG ... the HOF doesn't exist as far as I'm concerned.

This is the problem they will face with not allowing Monk in. He had very strong numbers so Reed poses a dilemna. They want to put Reed in, because the media LOVED that Bills team, but if they do, they have to answer for Monk and they don't have one. Witness P.K. trying to explain his vote. He can't because the real reason he won't vote for Monk is that he has always despised the Washington Redskins. Period. It's insane and it's an insult. Every other dynasty team gets their props except us. The Packers, the Raiders, the Steelers, the 49ers, soon the Cowboys, and the Vikings, My God, the Vikings. Apparently we won all of our Super Bowls on the strength of Coach Gibbs and John Riggins which is amazing since Riggins didn't play in the last two. Good for you, John!

The reality is that the Bills were a very good team in a lousy conference and some folks just never got the memo. (But they went to four straight Super Bowls. You can't forget that, blah, blah, blah). Exactly. The AFC was that bad. They had to send somebody.

I predict they will put Reed in before Monk and we'll hear how his impact was different than Monk's. (I just think that Reed really embodied the spirit of that team, yada, yada, yada). And they'll harp on the 19 TDs till they're blue in the face. Whatever they can think of to avoid telling the truth. And if you think I'm paranoid, check out the SportsCenter thread. More proof! I believe they have sent Tafkas to watch us. (Just kidding) (Maybe)


Chip you stole some of my thunder, Monk played in the toughest division in football for most of his career, as well in a much better confrence. Where as Reid had a cupcake ride in the AFC, if that Bill team played in the NFC east they would have been lucky to make the playoffs all 4 of those years let alone the SB.

It is true Reid had Lofton but Lofton was past his prime when he arrived in Buffalo, he didn't possess the dynamic recieving skills that made him one of the great recievers of his day, but he was a nice compliment to Reid.

Bottom line to many people despise the skins and refuse to vote for a guy like Monk, which just goes to prove that the HOF is nothing more than a popularity contest and whose A** you kiss the hardest, it has nothing to do with actual talent, as far as I am cocerned it's meaningless!

Harry Carson over Monk for the HOF give me a break!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Word!

I know this sounds crazy...but what we should do is petition to get Art monk in the hall of fame!

I know this sounds crazy...but what we should do is petition to get Art monk in the hall of fame!

http://www.thewarpath.net/Monk.htm

Scroll toward the bottom and thank Brud for his efforts