Defensewins
06-05-2004, 04:10 PM
I voted for other. I like Noble as a person and he is a great example of a great-hard working Redskin off the field. But as much as I want to see Noble and Haley step up a notch and move into the great players status with their play.... I can't help thinking there is little chance for that because (in my opinion) they lacking in basic raw physical talent to become really great. I think the best we can ever expect from them is they become average to slightly above average.
So I would want the Skins to start looking for a future replacement that has the potential to become an all-star. Sam Adams, if he is realeased, seems like the quickest/short term fix.
sportscurmudgeon
06-05-2004, 11:39 PM
Joe Crisp:
One more post like the one you did on the gap numbering system and we'll have to change your screen name to "The Perfesser".
Excellent explanation. I hope everyone here copies your message and saves it to their hard disk.
I really want Brandon Noble to be a starting DT and for him to be productive this year but it would be next to miraculous for that to happen. He may not be the best pairing with Griffin in terms of size but he is EXACTLY the kind of guy you want to have next to Griffin in terms of the effort Noble gives on every snap of the ball. The knock on Griffin is that he has a tendency to take plays off and sometimes to take a series off and last year to take a game off once in a while. For Noble to "take a play off" he has to be carried off the field...
joecrisp
06-06-2004, 09:17 AM
Joe Crisp:
One more post like the one you did on the gap numbering system and we'll have to change your screen name to "The Perfesser".
Excellent explanation. I hope everyone here copies your message and saves it to their hard disk.
I really want Brandon Noble to be a starting DT and for him to be productive this year but it would be next to miraculous for that to happen. He may not be the best pairing with Griffin in terms of size but he is EXACTLY the kind of guy you want to have next to Griffin in terms of the effort Noble gives on every snap of the ball. The knock on Griffin is that he has a tendency to take plays off and sometimes to take a series off and last year to take a game off once in a while. For Noble to "take a play off" he has to be carried off the field...
Thanks, SC! Your take on Noble and Griffin is dead-on. Noble truly deserves to be a starter, based on effort and heart alone. I'm definitely pulling for him, and praying that he'll earn that "miracle". Noble is able to overcome his size deficit as a nose guard through sheer effort and tenacity. Let's just hope that knee of his holds up and continues to improve.
Hopefully, with improved coaching from Williams and Blache, as well as the shining example of Noble working his tail off alongside him, Griffin will learn to be a more consistent player and put forth the kind of effort that Noble gives on every play. If that happens, then this D-line will be vastly improved.
I'd be willing to bet that as long as Noble is ready to go Gibbs will give him the starting nod in week 1 out of respect.
Noble should be effective in a rotation, I'm sure the staff will closely monitor his snaps.