MTK
08-28-2006, 02:44 PM
Much thanks to Rick as always for participating in these Q&A sessions with us!
Rick, it seems like this is a popular topic every year around this time. What's your take on the NFL preseason? Should it be shortened to 2 games?
I think two would be perfect. Of course, the NFL doesn't want to do it because it makes a ton of money on these games. Unlike regular-season games where even lowest-paid players make about $13,000, every player earns a flat fee in the preseason, which last time I checked was $500. Yet, the NFL still charges the same ticket prices and makes a lot of TV money. That's why the NFL doesn't want to go to 18 regular-season games. I think there won't be a change until after the 2012 labor pact ends.
How do other teams in the league view Ladell Betts? Does he have any real trade value?
Not really. I've always liked Betts and think he could be a decent back in the league, but he's already getting older and there are always shiny new players behind him. He's a role player and no one trades for that.
Stud RB Clinton Portis was hurt in the first quarter of a meaningless game. He later commented that He shouldn't have been in there, and that the preseason is too long.
My question is this. Do the Redskins have a reasonable expectation that Portis's preseason would exceed a dozen plays? He got injured on the eighth offensive snap, and while I don't want him hurt ever (because of my man-crush), his complaint seems invalid, unless he's advocating a seven snap pre-season.
Portis was just angry at the time. It was a fluke play and shouldn't dictate anything, really. Just bad luck.
Rick, what's your take on the Redskins secondary. It seems like the starting four have the potential to be the best corner/corner/saftey/saftey combination in the NFL, but if one of them (especially/specifically at the corner position) do you see the Redskins defense taking a big step back?
I worry Shawn Springs won't be 100 percent this season and that hurts. They are a solid foursome when healthy, but Arch is still learning the system and they don't have a backup corner to use in the nickel and dime packages, much less start.
Rick, is there enough depth in camp this year backing up the current "Hogs"?
Probably not. They had a couple veterans last year who are gone and now they're down to kids, which you never know how they'll do. Then again, the starting five hasn't looked good in the preseason.
How badly does Collins have to play and how well does Campbell have to play in order for Campbell to move up to #2 on the depth chart?
I'm with you on this. Gibbs is very reluctant to play someone with no experience, though Collins sure doesn't have much recent experience. I think Collins is No. 2 for the simple reason that in an emergency situation, Gibbs feels Collins wouldn't lose a game. That's more important than winning one in you understand that. Campbell is turnover-prone like any other unplayed player. From what I've seen of Campbell on the practice field, he can be something special.
If Shawn Springs has lingering injuries all season long, will the Skins safeties still be able to blitz and/or play close to the line of scrimmage? Overall how will his injury effect the entire defense?
His absence leaves them very vulnerable. Don't be surprised if the Redskins sign a corner in the next week. Obviously, the safeties can't blitz as much if the team lacks confidence in the corners.
I have three serious questions and one kind of silly one.
Is it proper form to put mayo on a cheesesteak?
Absolutely, but understand this is coming from somewhat who suffered a heart attack in 2002 so take that advice for what it's worth. Actually, I no longer use mayo on anything unless it's fat free, and the latter really isn't that bad.
What condiments are on a Rick Snider hot dog?
OK, I don't really eat hot dogs anymore because of the heart attack (and bypass surgery) aside from a fat free one. And guys, they really aren't so bad. But I always loved ketchup and yellow mustard. No relish or onions or chili or cheese. Keep it real, baby.
Pizza: Deep Dish or Thin Crust?
I love answering food questions. As Spurrier always said, it's all good. I can eat both, but I guess deep dish in the end. I was in Chicago last week on vacation (first one during football in 23 years since I'm now a columnist who doesn't have to see every sunset at Redskin Park anymore) and ate lunch at the very first Uno's. Place was very small and the pizza crust was like pie crust, which I didn't like as much but did feel me up.)
What is the minimum that must happen this season for it to be considered a successful season?
Super Bowl appearance. I'm not kidding. Anything less would be a disappointment despite the preseason. I see the team going 10-6 and then Gibbs gets them to the finals only to lose (sorry) to Indianapolis.
Do you see the Skins making a move to aquire a more experienced and capable backup OT than is currently on the roster? I know they signed Folau, but he just seems like another name on the roster. Since coming back Bugel hasn't really found or taught any of the OL to be any good (except for one Ray Brown), so that's a spot i'm a bit worried about.
If someone comes loose on the final waivers, it's possible another OT, but I doubt it.
Could losing any one other player than jansen or samuels be a worse loss? And why didn't the Skins try to at least pretend to bring in competition at punter?
Punter? How about another kicker? I really think they should cut Hall if possible. It has always been one thing or another. Great guy, but no long kickoffs and injuries make him expendable. OK, back to your question, they did bring in a free agent to punt, but nothing happened. I would be shocked if the team doesn't sign a new punter this week, though. As for losing one of the tackles, no one on the OL would be worse, but certainly there are others like Brunell and Portis who would be worse losses.
Rick, where do you see Duckett fitting in? Does he bump Betts from the main backup, or is he mainly a short-yardage and goal line back?
I think Duckett becomes the main backup.
Rick, how should we read into this miserable preseason? Is the season really in jeopardy or is this going to be just another losing preseason under Gibbs that turns out to mean nothing in the long run?
That's the question we've been arguing for a week with no answer. Who knows? We've seen Gibbs win three titles after 0-4, 1-3 and 1-3. I think anything can happen, but never judge the preseason too harshly.
Hey, it has been lots of fun. Love the food questions. I hope you'll read me most days in the Washington Examiner at dcexaminer.com. -- Rick
Rick, it seems like this is a popular topic every year around this time. What's your take on the NFL preseason? Should it be shortened to 2 games?
I think two would be perfect. Of course, the NFL doesn't want to do it because it makes a ton of money on these games. Unlike regular-season games where even lowest-paid players make about $13,000, every player earns a flat fee in the preseason, which last time I checked was $500. Yet, the NFL still charges the same ticket prices and makes a lot of TV money. That's why the NFL doesn't want to go to 18 regular-season games. I think there won't be a change until after the 2012 labor pact ends.
How do other teams in the league view Ladell Betts? Does he have any real trade value?
Not really. I've always liked Betts and think he could be a decent back in the league, but he's already getting older and there are always shiny new players behind him. He's a role player and no one trades for that.
Stud RB Clinton Portis was hurt in the first quarter of a meaningless game. He later commented that He shouldn't have been in there, and that the preseason is too long.
My question is this. Do the Redskins have a reasonable expectation that Portis's preseason would exceed a dozen plays? He got injured on the eighth offensive snap, and while I don't want him hurt ever (because of my man-crush), his complaint seems invalid, unless he's advocating a seven snap pre-season.
Portis was just angry at the time. It was a fluke play and shouldn't dictate anything, really. Just bad luck.
Rick, what's your take on the Redskins secondary. It seems like the starting four have the potential to be the best corner/corner/saftey/saftey combination in the NFL, but if one of them (especially/specifically at the corner position) do you see the Redskins defense taking a big step back?
I worry Shawn Springs won't be 100 percent this season and that hurts. They are a solid foursome when healthy, but Arch is still learning the system and they don't have a backup corner to use in the nickel and dime packages, much less start.
Rick, is there enough depth in camp this year backing up the current "Hogs"?
Probably not. They had a couple veterans last year who are gone and now they're down to kids, which you never know how they'll do. Then again, the starting five hasn't looked good in the preseason.
How badly does Collins have to play and how well does Campbell have to play in order for Campbell to move up to #2 on the depth chart?
I'm with you on this. Gibbs is very reluctant to play someone with no experience, though Collins sure doesn't have much recent experience. I think Collins is No. 2 for the simple reason that in an emergency situation, Gibbs feels Collins wouldn't lose a game. That's more important than winning one in you understand that. Campbell is turnover-prone like any other unplayed player. From what I've seen of Campbell on the practice field, he can be something special.
If Shawn Springs has lingering injuries all season long, will the Skins safeties still be able to blitz and/or play close to the line of scrimmage? Overall how will his injury effect the entire defense?
His absence leaves them very vulnerable. Don't be surprised if the Redskins sign a corner in the next week. Obviously, the safeties can't blitz as much if the team lacks confidence in the corners.
I have three serious questions and one kind of silly one.
Is it proper form to put mayo on a cheesesteak?
Absolutely, but understand this is coming from somewhat who suffered a heart attack in 2002 so take that advice for what it's worth. Actually, I no longer use mayo on anything unless it's fat free, and the latter really isn't that bad.
What condiments are on a Rick Snider hot dog?
OK, I don't really eat hot dogs anymore because of the heart attack (and bypass surgery) aside from a fat free one. And guys, they really aren't so bad. But I always loved ketchup and yellow mustard. No relish or onions or chili or cheese. Keep it real, baby.
Pizza: Deep Dish or Thin Crust?
I love answering food questions. As Spurrier always said, it's all good. I can eat both, but I guess deep dish in the end. I was in Chicago last week on vacation (first one during football in 23 years since I'm now a columnist who doesn't have to see every sunset at Redskin Park anymore) and ate lunch at the very first Uno's. Place was very small and the pizza crust was like pie crust, which I didn't like as much but did feel me up.)
What is the minimum that must happen this season for it to be considered a successful season?
Super Bowl appearance. I'm not kidding. Anything less would be a disappointment despite the preseason. I see the team going 10-6 and then Gibbs gets them to the finals only to lose (sorry) to Indianapolis.
Do you see the Skins making a move to aquire a more experienced and capable backup OT than is currently on the roster? I know they signed Folau, but he just seems like another name on the roster. Since coming back Bugel hasn't really found or taught any of the OL to be any good (except for one Ray Brown), so that's a spot i'm a bit worried about.
If someone comes loose on the final waivers, it's possible another OT, but I doubt it.
Could losing any one other player than jansen or samuels be a worse loss? And why didn't the Skins try to at least pretend to bring in competition at punter?
Punter? How about another kicker? I really think they should cut Hall if possible. It has always been one thing or another. Great guy, but no long kickoffs and injuries make him expendable. OK, back to your question, they did bring in a free agent to punt, but nothing happened. I would be shocked if the team doesn't sign a new punter this week, though. As for losing one of the tackles, no one on the OL would be worse, but certainly there are others like Brunell and Portis who would be worse losses.
Rick, where do you see Duckett fitting in? Does he bump Betts from the main backup, or is he mainly a short-yardage and goal line back?
I think Duckett becomes the main backup.
Rick, how should we read into this miserable preseason? Is the season really in jeopardy or is this going to be just another losing preseason under Gibbs that turns out to mean nothing in the long run?
That's the question we've been arguing for a week with no answer. Who knows? We've seen Gibbs win three titles after 0-4, 1-3 and 1-3. I think anything can happen, but never judge the preseason too harshly.
Hey, it has been lots of fun. Love the food questions. I hope you'll read me most days in the Washington Examiner at dcexaminer.com. -- Rick