Redskins best free agent move

I was just on redskins.com. The poll was about wich free agent would be the most productive.
To my suprise Antwaan Randle El has 56% of the vote and the next best is at
16.3%
I thought Brandon Lloyd would of won that hands down.

What do the hardcore Warpath Redskins fans think?

I was just on redskins.com. The poll was about wich free agent would be the most productive.
To my suprise Antwaan Randle El has 56% of the vote and the next best is at
16.3%
I thought Brandon Lloyd would of won that hands down.

What do the hardcore Warpath Redskins fans think?

I say Andre Carter

Adam Archuleta easily for me. he will have atleast 5 sacks this year and will be a monster just pressuring the qb and confusing the offenses

Carter and then Collins for a backup...and tendering Dockery would be my 3rd

I second Andre Carter. While I think Randle El and Lloyd will do wonders for the passing attack, Carter is going to put the defense "over the top." Carter has the most potential of our FA acquisitions, he's going to free up a lot of people to stay back in coverage, and he's extremely versatile (not that Randle El isn't).

If we don't end up with a top 3 defense, I'd be shocked.

Adam Archuleta easily for me. he will have atleast 5 sacks this year and will be a monster just pressuring the qb and confusing the offenses

I like Arch too, but I actually think he's probably got the least potential of the group. He's older and we've seen what he can do. Randle El was working in a run-first defense and he's young. Lloyd is also young and it's amazing that he had any receptions given who was throwing the ball. I love signing Carter (provided he's healthy). So, while I really like Arch, I like the other free agents more.

I like Arch too, but I actually think he's probably got the least potential of the group. He's older and we've seen what he can do. Randle El was working in a run-first defense and he's young. Lloyd is also young and it's amazing that he had any receptions given who was throwing the ball. I love signing Carter (provided he's healthy). So, while I really like Arch, I like the other free agents more.

i disagree. arch isnt exactly old, he is 28. also, his whole career he played a much less aggressive, less talented defensie scheme. under williams, he will be able to blitz often which is his main strength. he fits perfectly into our system. he was in cover 2 his whole career, now he is coming to one of the top defenses in the league that plays to his strengths

carter. carter is the only clearly great player and he'll take our #1 spot.

lloyd and El are #2 and #3, and El is a PK return guy. arch is the #2 safety and has an obviously hole in his game (in coverage).

To be honest we have no clue what we are going to get from these guys. There are question marks surrounding all the players we have signed but if Carter gets motivated he might be the best addition. I also think Archuleta can be a monster near the line. With GW on his side I can see Archuleta getting 8 to 10 sacks and a number of FF. Having said all of that I go with Randle because of his versatility :biggthump

In the long run I think it will be either Arch or R El...they both have alot of improving to do...B Lloyd's best years are to come too.