American Idol Hotness

For anyone who watches this show, there's a fine crop of talent (among other things). Who's your pick based on talent and looks?

I am so all over this show, as I am every single year. I sang in college, so I tend to be a critic in addition to having personal favorites. My picks to win often differ from my own personal tastes.

Female best singer: Mandisa
Female most attractive: Katharine McPhee (oh boy oh boy oh boy)
Female likely to go furthest in competition: Lisa Tucker

Male best singer: Chris Dautry
Male most attractive: not going there
Male likely to go furthest in competition: Chris Dautry

The Schneed10 pick to win: Chris Dautry

I also like Taylor Hicks (is it just me, or should he come on stage wearing overalls, a fake beard, and Dapper Dan pomade in his hair to sing A Man of Constant Sorrow or what??), and Kellie Pickler makes me laugh.

I don't like Mandisa but I can't deny her talent, and I think she's going to lose a few votes for being heavy eventually. I think it will come down to her and Lisa for the top girl, and Lisa will take it. I pick Lisa Tucker to go far because it's only a matter of time before she picks the right song to wow the crowd. Plus she's unflappable on stage, never gets nervous.

Katharine McPhee is by far my favorite chick. She has the prettiest voice, and she's by far the best looking IMO. But she lacks stage command.

But as much as I like her, my favorite is Chris Dautry. Dude can just straight bring it, that rendition of Fuel's Hemorrhage was friggin brilliant. I'm excited to see what he does tonight.

McPhee is fine as hell. Do you not think that Kellie Pickler is just the cutest thing you've ever seen. Like normally I describe attractive girls as hot but this girl is just cute as hell. Yeah, I'm picking Dautry to win too. Guy has an amazing talent. I thought that Paris had the best "voice" of anybody so far.

Melissa McSomething is bangin' too. Too bad her voice isn't better. I like that raspy sound from chick voices.

Melissa McSomething is bangin' too. Too bad her voice isn't better. I like that raspy sound from chick voices.

She's a good lookin one, you're right. Melissa McGhee. McPhee and McGhee. Just funny.

She has a cool tone to her voice, it's like it's smoky or something. But her range is limited, she can't sing high notes very well, that limits her.

http://www.katharine-mcphee.net/images/pink_02.pnghttp://www.katharine-mcphee.net/images/pink_03.png

Good GRACIOUS.

HA! I meant to paste the whole pic but I guess that banner had an upper and lower half!! LOL LOL

EDIT: Fixed.

McPhee is fine as hell. Do you not think that Kellie Pickler is just the cutest thing you've ever seen. Like normally I describe attractive girls as hot but this girl is just cute as hell. Yeah, I'm picking Dautry to win too. Guy has an amazing talent. I thought that Paris had the best "voice" of anybody so far.

Yeah definitely. Of the chicks that are left, Katharine is that girl in school that you can't stop thinking about because she's so hot. But Kellie is the one you really want to be your girlfriend. That's the best way I can describe it.

The looks are great, the personality is stellar, and they comprise a whole that is much greater than the sum of those two parts.

That's exactly how I would have put it. Did you know that Donahue chick that was kicked off posed in Maxim with her twin last year before Idol?

That's exactly how I would have put it. Did you know that Donahue chick that was kicked off posed in Maxim with her twin last year before Idol?

I sure did, I practically have the link bookmarked!

http://www.maximonline.com/girls_of_maxim/pictures_and_bio/1209/AmericanIdolTwins.girl

Heather Cox was a looker too. Too bad they cut her loose.